We visit the Pelican Club and discover a hidden gem of jazz, cheese and Italian food

The Pelican Club offers incredible pasta dishesplaceholder image
The Pelican Club offers incredible pasta dishes | Caroline Barry

When it comes to traditional Italian food, Nottingham has a few restaurants with a truly authentic feel but few that hit the mark quite like The Pelican Club

You can’t go wrong with a classic Italian dish as it will usually contain at least three of the major food groups - cheese, pasta and truffles. As Nottingham has a few exceptional Italian Venues, I decided to put one to the test with a trip to The Pelican Club on St. Mary’s Place.

You’d be forgiven for walking past the quiet restaurant which is tucked into the left of the street through mysterious glass doors. Entering means you have to slide the thick curtain to one side and battle your way through but stick with it as you step into a cosy, intimate restaurant with a giant neon pelican.

I can be quite picky when it comes to Italian food which I put down to living in Umbria for a year. I ran away from Nottingham to teach English for a year and when I left, the highlight of my culinary skills was exploding an egg onto the ceiling of a bedsit. I wasn’t exactly a connoisseur or a chef of any description. However, a year with access to fresh food, cheap yet excellent local wines and freshly dug-up truffles did wonders for me and I came back having developed an interest in food.

This is why I was curious about The Pelican Club as it offers good, classic Umrbian dishes and ingredients such as Pecrino cheeses, truffles, venison and cured meats. I had my food education in Foligno, bang in the middle of Umbria so I was determined to give this a good go.

I decided to start with the ‘Crostone alle Verdure,’ which consisted of roasted Mediterranean vegetables topped with buffalo mozzarella served on crunchy bruschetta - although hold the crumbled sausage for this vegetarian though. I was impressed with the offering that arrived as both slices of fresh, crusty bread was piled high with vegetables and thick mozzarella so beautifully done I could have gone home happy after that. There is a special place in my heart for Italian vegetables grilled as nowhere else does them quite the same.

Bruscetta at The Pelican Club in Nottinghamplaceholder image
Bruscetta at The Pelican Club in Nottingham | Caroline Barry

I also believe in, ‘go carbs or go home’ so for my second course I opted to get stuck into some freshly made gnocchi. The dish had soft potato gnocchi served in a creamy truffle sauce with pan-fried courgette. Truffle can be hit or miss, as too much is overpowering and you can taste it for days. However, too little can leave you feeling as if you have nothing but oil in your pasta. I’m happy to report that Pelican Club managed an exceptional blend of just enough without it feeling too oily.

One of the best parts about Pelican Club is the wonderful relaxed atmosphere and anything goes. A group of Italian diners sat together catching up while two women beside us celebrated a birthday with Pornstar Martinis while listening to the soft sounds of the Cat Mancini jazz band. A first date rocked up towards the end of the night to listen to live music while enjoying an espresso martini.

I’ve never had much of a sweet tooth so I prefer to have a cheese board to round off an evening. Here is where the Pelican Club outdid itself. I judge a place based on the size of the cheese slice they serve and have been known to cross a return visit off a list if I deem the slice a bit on the thin side.

This wasn’t the case with The Pelican Club as a loaded cheese board arrived groaning with Italian cheeses, grapes and pesto. Absolutely delighted with myself, I polished the lot off but I have to note, it was an impressive spread. I did go off the menu with the cheeseboard but the staff were incredibly friendly, quick and not fazed by my request.

All in all, the meal was a relaxed, otherwordly evening where it felt as if we had been transported from the streets of Nottingham to the middle of Umbria. It was a bit of a shock when we left to find ourselves back out in the cold of the Lace Market but we left smiling with a determination to go back.

Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice