Travellers in Nottinghamshire 'left in limbo' as flood risks stall permanent sites
Travellers in Nottinghamshire face uncertainty as flood risks delay permanent site permissions, with councils granting temporary extensions.
Councillors say Gypsy and Traveller families living at a large site in Newark continue to be left “in limbo” over their futures.
A number of residents of the Tolney Lane site have been looking to get permanent planning permission from Newark and Sherwood District Council to give them more certainty over where they can live.
However the authority’s officers said there were “significant flood risk concerns” and recommended an extension to temporary planning consent should be given instead.
At a Planning Committee meeting on Thursday (July 3), planning permissions for two separate sites at Tolney Lane were considered.
The first site is located at Shannon Falls, on the northern side of Tolney Lane, and is included in the council’s plan for the allocation of land to Travellers – which is currently at a draft stage.
It has existed on temporary permission since 2022.
Planning officer Kirsty Catlow said: “There is currently a significant unmet need for Gypsy and Traveller accommodation in Newark and Sherwood.
“However the proposed use is classed as highly vulnerable and incompatible with the level of flood risk.”
The council’s Draft Amended Allocations & Development Management DPD was submitted to the Government’s Planning Inspectorate for examination back in January 2024, however the results have not yet been published.
A flood mitigation scheme for the site is also being planned to help make it safer.
Given the delay, Ms Catlow said it was reasonable to consider temporary consent for an additional year to allow the land allocation process to conclude and give residents certainty.
However a resident who spoke at the meeting said he had put his “life savings” into the plot, and said: “We understand Tolney Lane is a flood risk area, but due to our culture we can put those caravans on the back of a transit van or a lorry and we can shift them up to the lorry park.
“We understand where we live and we understand risks of flooding.”
Cllr Linda Dales (Con), a member of the committee, said: “Here we are again. I empathise with the speaker. I can only hope the inspector comes back to us with an answer soon.
“In the meantime this is an allocated site within the development plan, and I do think that affords it weight.”
Cllr Peter Harris (Lib Dem) suggested the temporary consent be extended by two years.
Cllr Emma Oldham (Green) agreed and said: “Residents have been in limbo. A two-year extension is a good idea.”
Councillors agreed to extend temporary permission by two years to August 1, 2027.
The second site, located at Sandhills Sconce on the south-west end of Tolney Lane, has been permitted on a temporary basis since 2014.
However it does not sit within the Tolney Lane land allocation in the council’s plan.
Cllr Dales said, “I would be reluctant to support any more than a one-year extension on this one.”
Cllr Harris added: “It may not be part of the allocated sites, but it might well be, to be honest.
“I do think it should be a two-year extension.”
Council officers said councillors should think about the outcome of what the Planning Inspectorate decides, and “be cautious” by favouring the officer recommendation of one year.
Cllr Keith Melton (Lib Dem) said: “It is more humane for people to know where they are for as long as possible.”
A motion calling for an extension for the second site by two years failed, and permission was only granted for a year.
